Up close of pink blooming flowers

Threatening Grace: Why the Gospel Disrupts Our Comfort Zones

I vividly remember driving my eldest child home from the hospital after her birth. I was ready to be home. My wife was ready to stay in the hospital for another week. We were exploding with love, yet we were also grappling with fear. The comfort zone of home was about to be disrupted in the best way. To put it bluntly, this beautiful little life was a threat to life as we knew it. We could no longer trust our robotic routines—we couldn’t wing parenting and hope it worked out, sticking to the status quo. We learned quickly how much we needed to learn, and the things we did know felt alarmingly limited. Our life was now stretched, flexible, and even seemingly insecure. This little grace, this child, changed everything. It was a threat from God that, in changing everything, changed us.

The grace of Christ threatens our lives in a similar way. Grace is a beauty from the heart of Christ that cannot leave us the same. It affirms our insufficiency. It rebukes our self-reliance. It exposes our ignorance. It disrupts our superficial securities. When the grace of the gospel kicks down the door of your heart, it pushes against the comfort zones within. Yet once it takes up residence there, you find that it builds up, heals, and transforms. It does not threaten all that is good, beautiful, and holy about our lives; it threatens the parts of us that are unlike Christ. Let me suggest four ways the grace of the gospel threatens the comfort zones of the soul.

When You Think You Can Earn God’s Favor

Legalism is a hard-wired comfort zone of the soul. A list of rules seems easier than a life yielded to God’s ways. When I say “legalism,” I don’t mean merely stricter standards or harder lines on holiness. (Most of us, if we’re honest, probably need harder lines on holiness.) I am referring to true legalism, which suggests that I can leverage myself into greater favor with God through better performance of His law. To borrow David’s confession in Psalm 51:16–17, legalists believe the sacrifices that please God are the ones offered professionally, perfectly, and performatively. But David’s point in Psalm 51 is that true devotion is proven not in heartless performance of the Law but in desperate repentance before the Lord. To the self-righteous, a Christianity of performance always seems less vulnerable than a Christianity of repentance.

The Law is a comfort zone for the rule-keeper. The obvious problem here, though, is that none of us are true law-keepers. Our only consistency in relation to the Law is our tendency to fall short of it. It’s a comfort zone with walls too high to scale. We keep climbing but never reach safety, for no safety exists there. By its very nature, grace is hard to receive while we refuse to admit our—and the Law’s—insufficiency. Pride stiff-arms God, but He gives grace to the humble (James 4:6). Grace secures those who admit their insufficiency. Legalism is like the Trojan horse—our hearts lean toward law-keeping, so we welcome it in, but the very Law we trust condemns us. Grace intends to threaten the legalist in you. Releasing our law-keeping ways is uncomfortable, but once we do we can rejoice in Christ’s sufficiency and let go of the insecurity of a standard we cannot meet.

When You Treat Grace as a License to Sin

Opposite the legalist is the libertine. Unlike the legalist, who measures their success by the Law, the libertine doesn’t measure themselves by anything at all. Libertines live as though the Law doesn’t apply to them because Jesus paid it all. They treat every prohibition as the “Law” from which we’ve been freed. They view God as a permissive parent allowing tantrums and chaotic behavior without penalty or enforcement.

They want Jesus. They want church. They want encouraging and maybe even biblical preaching. They want to serve. They want to be influential for good. What they cannot abide, though, is accountability. They require a world where their sin is tolerated. True grace is a threat to the libertine because it requires transformation, not toleration. Grace fundamentally says that we’re not okay, which collides with the libertine’s self-evaluation.

The Christian life is lived in community. As we grow close to other Christians, it becomes harder to hide our flaws. God has a plan for this: He expects His people to challenge one another (Proverbs 27:6, Galatians 6:1, 1 Thessalonians 5:14). When a repentant Christian sees their sin clearly, even (or perhaps especially) if someone else brought it to their attention, they aren’t threatened and defensive. They are serious and reflective. Grace at its core assumes you always need more of it. The libertine usually has a keen eye for how others need more grace but cannot abide looking into “the perfect law of liberty” (James 1:25, NKJV). What that Law reveals is uglier than how they see themselves.

When You Believe You Have to Do It All Yourself

You may not identify as a legalist or a libertine (though I think both live in us more than we realize). But this next threat addresses all of us to some extent. Grace threatens the self-reliant. Grace cannot allow us to operate as though sufficiency is inside us and all we need to do is find the right mechanism to draw it out. Grace does its work in those humble enough to acknowledge the limits of their finiteness and the depths of their sinfulness.

Grace threatens us with the reality that we are too finite to make anything of our lives in our own strength. Paul reminds the Corinthians that our weakness—our inability to do the very things Christ has called us to—is fertile ground for grace to flourish (2 Corinthians 12:9–10). Today, we can rest in this humbling hope: The good that comes from our lives doesn’t come from us. If it did, we’d need to keep producing it—and we can’t. We need not drum up greater goodness inside ourselves. That’s drawing water from an empty well. Grace calls us to rest in the goodness of depending on Christ, not the exhausting belief that Christ depends upon us.

Grace threatens a view of sanctification that is self-strengthened and self-sustained. Scripture grounds our sanctification in Christ’s sufficiency, not our own (Galatians 2:20). When Christ saved us from the bondage of sin, He didn’t say, “Now you take it from here!” Grace threatens the thinking that we need more of Jesus to be saved and more of ourselves to be sanctified. How exhausting and discouraging our lives become when we believe that “he who began a good work in you” (Philippians 1:6, ESV) left the rest for you to finish. When we yield to the truth that we are not enough—but Christ is—we will find ourselves trusting more and striving less.

When Your Theological Knowledge Runs Out

Theological intellect without heart affection is a house of cards. This superficial comfort zone is easily toppled by suffering, by perceived injustice, or by experiences that don’t match our theological education. It is a jarring feeling when God teaches us something about Himself that seems outside what we knew of Him. When our knowledge fails us, we are met with our need.

We see this need beautifully on display when Mary ponders the depths and mysteries of bearing and birthing the Messiah. First, note that Mary was clearly knowledgeable. Her Magnificat (Luke 1:46–55) is overflowing with the Old Testament.1 This young woman knew the Scriptures inside and out. Yet her faith collided with fear, her hopes with humiliation, and her understanding with her experience. In that moment, she dwelt on her need more than anything else. The Magnificat is a worshipful meditation upon God’s care for those in greatest need. In the complexity of her life and situation, Mary wasn’t comforted by what she knew but by whom she needed to know more fully.

Your theological knowledge will run out, but Christ’s grace won’t. It is a grace of the gospel to learn that there’s little we actually know. Christ will meet you where you haven’t been in order to teach you what you do not know.

When legalism condemns you or untethered liberty leads you astray, grace brings you to safety. When you’re exhausted by your efforts to put your life together in your own strength, Christ assures you that grace is not for the already put-together. When you learn you have more to learn, grace invites you to learn of Christ. It is a glory of the gospel to yield to the threats of grace.

If you liked this article, check out the related resources linked below!

Notes:

1. By some counts, the Magnificat contains twenty or more Old Testament quotations or allusions.


Author Bio

Kyle Grant is the pastor of Grace Bible Church in Elkhart, Indiana. He is married to Julia, and they have three children. Kyle has an undergraduate degree in Bible, an MA in Biblical Studies, and a Doctor of Ministry in Preaching and Teaching from Knox Seminary. He writes on matters of family and parenting at growingfathers.com. He also serves as an adjunct professor at various Christian colleges and universities.

×

Unlock a 10% off coupon!

Related Resources:

By Faith | Galatians Study In Christ Alone | Romans Bible Study You're Not Enough: The Gospel is the Better Way

Loading price…

Loading price…

Add to Cart Add to Cart View Blog